Bad news for parents who post every moment of their child’s life online: psychologists are sounding the alarm ‘It’s my kid, my choice’ – a story that splits families and friendships

Sarah’s fingers hover over the “Delete” button for the hundredth time this week. Her 14-year-old daughter discovered the family Instagram account last month – five years of bath time giggles, potty training victories, and tearful first-day-of-school photos. Now her teen won’t speak to her.

“Mom, how could you put my naked baby pictures online for strangers to see?” she’d screamed before slamming her bedroom door. Sarah thought she was being a loving, proud parent. Her daughter feels betrayed and exposed.

This scene plays out in homes across the country as sharenting dangers become impossible to ignore. What started as innocent family sharing has evolved into something much more complex – and potentially harmful.

When Family Photos Become Public Property

Sharenting – the practice of parents sharing content about their children on social media – has exploded beyond simple birthday posts. Today’s parents document everything from diaper blowouts to report cards, creating detailed digital biographies before their children can even spell their own names.

Dr. Jennifer Walsh, a child psychologist specializing in digital wellness, sees the fallout daily. “Parents think they’re celebrating their kids, but they’re actually making irreversible decisions about their child’s digital identity without consent,” she explains.

The numbers tell the story. Research shows that 92% of American children have an online presence before their second birthday. Some appear in their first social media post within hours of birth.

But the real shock comes when these children grow up and discover their entire childhood has been public entertainment.

The Hidden Costs Nobody Talks About

The sharenting dangers extend far beyond embarrassing baby photos. Mental health professionals are documenting serious consequences that many parents never considered:

  • Identity theft risks: Birth dates, full names, and locations frequently appear in posts
  • Future employment concerns: College admissions and job recruiters increasingly check social media histories
  • Bullying ammunition: Classmates use old posts as material for teasing and harassment
  • Loss of privacy: Children have no control over their own narrative or image
  • Family relationship damage: Trust breaks down when kids feel exploited
Age Group Most Common Concern Long-term Impact
0-5 years Privacy invasion No digital consent given
6-12 years Peer embarrassment Social anxiety and bullying
13-18 years Reputation management College and career implications
Adult children Ongoing privacy loss Permanent digital footprint

“I had a 16-year-old patient who couldn’t apply to certain programs because her mother’s posts from years ago painted her as having behavioral issues,” says Dr. Walsh. “The internet never forgets.”

When Families Break Apart Over Photos

The sharenting debate isn’t just about children – it’s tearing families and friendships apart. Parents who question oversharing often face explosive reactions from those who see criticism as an attack on their parenting choices.

Maria Rodriguez learned this the hard way when she asked her sister to stop posting videos of her nephew’s meltdowns. “She told me I was jealous because I didn’t have kids,” Maria recalls. “We haven’t spoken in eight months.”

Child development expert Dr. Michael Chen observes this pattern repeatedly. “Parents become defensive because they genuinely believe they’re doing something positive. They see likes and comments as validation of their parenting.”

The “it’s my kid, my choice” argument has become a rallying cry, but legal experts point out this logic has limits. Several countries are considering laws that would give children the right to request removal of content featuring them.

France already allows minors to demand social media platforms remove content posted by their parents. Similar legislation is being discussed in the United States.

The Psychology Behind the Posting

Understanding why parents overshare requires looking beyond simple pride. Social media provides instant validation during the often-isolating experience of raising children.

Dr. Sarah Kim, a family therapist, explains the deeper motivations: “Parents, especially new mothers, are seeking connection and reassurance. Each like feels like approval that they’re doing parenthood right.”

The algorithm amplifies this behavior. Platforms prioritize engaging content, and children’s milestones and mishaps generate high engagement. Parents unknowingly become content creators with their kids as unwilling stars.

But the psychological cost to children can be severe. Kids report feeling like their worth depends on online performance. Some develop anxiety about living up to their curated online image.

Finding the Middle Ground

Not all sharing is harmful, but experts recommend strict boundaries. The key is considering the child’s future perspective on every post.

Safe sharing practices include:

  • Avoiding photos showing nudity, tantrums, or private moments
  • Never including full names, birth dates, or location details
  • Asking older children for permission before posting
  • Keeping accounts private with limited followers
  • Regular digital detoxes to focus on real-world connections

Some families are adopting “sharenting contracts” – agreements about what can and cannot be shared online. Others create private family albums instead of public posts.

The most important step is honest family conversation. Dr. Chen suggests asking children how they feel about their online presence, even young ones who might not fully understand the implications yet.

FAQs

Is it illegal to post photos of my own children online?
Currently legal in most places, but some countries are implementing laws giving children more control over their digital presence.

How do I know if I’m sharing too much about my kids?
Ask yourself: Would I want this posted about me at their age? Would this embarrass them as adults?

What should I do if family members overshare about my children?
Have a calm, private conversation focusing on safety and privacy concerns rather than parenting criticism.

Can children really be harmed by innocent baby photos?
Yes – identity theft, future embarrassment, and loss of privacy control are real risks that can impact them for decades.

How can I stay connected with family without oversharing?
Use private messaging, shared family albums with restricted access, or video calls instead of public posts.

What age should children have input on their social media presence?
Experts recommend asking children as young as 5-6 years old for permission, and giving teenagers full veto power over posts featuring them.

Leave a Comment