Margaret Thompson had been teaching elementary school for 35 years when she retired in 2018, looking forward to her teacher’s pension and Social Security benefits. But when her Social Security check arrived, it was hundreds of dollars less than she expected due to the Windfall Elimination Provision. “I felt cheated,” she recalls. “I paid into Social Security my entire career, just like everyone else.”
Last month, Margaret received a surprise: a lump sum payment of $18,000 and her monthly Social Security benefit jumped from $800 to $1,400. The Social Security Fairness Act had finally eliminated the policies that reduced her benefits for decades.
But now Margaret faces a new concern—a potentially hefty tax bill on that retroactive payment that could eat into her windfall.
What the Social Security Fairness Act Changed
The Social Security Fairness Act of 2025 marked a historic victory for public-sector workers, eliminating two controversial provisions that had reduced benefits for 3.2 million Americans. The Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and Government Pension Offset (GPO) had long been criticized as unfair penalties on teachers, firefighters, police officers, and other public servants.
- No one saw this coming: Your state determines how much Social Security you’ll get in 2026
- Millions don’t know they’re owed money from Trump’s illegal tariff ruling
- What Diplo just agreed to do at the Olympics has everyone talking
- No one saw this coming at the 2026 Olympics figure skating gala…
- No one saw this coming when they found bloody gloves near Nancy Guthrie’s home
- This quiet Sunday habit is saving drivers up to $10 every fill-up
The WEP, enacted in 1983, reduced Social Security benefits for workers who also received pensions from jobs where they didn’t pay Social Security taxes. The formula was complex, but essentially penalized workers who split their careers between public and private sector employment. The GPO, also from 1983, reduced Social Security spousal or survivor benefits by two-thirds of the government pension amount, often eliminating these benefits entirely.
These provisions affected workers differently based on their career paths and pension amounts. A teacher who worked 20 years in public schools and 20 years in private industry could see their Social Security benefits reduced by up to $587 per month under the WEP. Similarly, a widow receiving a teacher’s pension might lose all her deceased husband’s Social Security survivor benefits due to the GPO.
The law restored full Social Security benefits retroactively to January 2024, meaning eligible recipients received both one-time lump sum payments covering the past year and increased monthly benefits going forward. The retroactive payments varied significantly—some recipients received a few hundred dollars, while others, like Margaret, received tens of thousands.
“For hundreds of thousands of Americans, the bipartisan Social Security Fairness Act was truly transformative, ensuring they received the benefits they deserved,” said Rep. Chellie Pingree, D-Maine. However, she added a crucial caveat: “But it was never intended to saddle widows, low-income seniors, and dedicated public servants with an unexpected tax bill.”
Key Changes and Who Benefits
The repeal primarily affects specific groups of public-sector workers who were previously subject to these reductions. Understanding eligibility is crucial for determining whether you qualify for restored benefits.
Eligible Workers Include:
- Teachers and education professionals in state pension systems
- Police officers and firefighters with municipal pensions
- Local government employees in non-Social Security covered positions
- Federal workers hired before December 31, 1983 (CSRS system)
- State and municipal workers with separate pension systems
- Railroad workers under certain circumstances
- Some foreign government employees
Benefits That Remain Unaffected:
- Military pensions (never subject to WEP or GPO)
- VA disability benefits
- Foreign government payments under totalization agreements
- 401(k) and other defined contribution plans
- Private sector pensions
The restoration applies to full Tier I benefits, with ongoing payments now reflecting the complete amount workers earned through their Social Security contributions. The calculation now uses the standard Primary Insurance Amount formula without the WEP reduction, potentially increasing monthly benefits by $300-600 or more depending on work history and pension amounts.
For survivor benefits, the GPO elimination means widows and widowers can now receive their full spousal benefits alongside their government pensions. Previously, many received nothing due to the two-thirds offset rule.
Most beneficiaries require no action unless they’ve changed addresses or banking information, which can be reported to the Social Security Administration at (800) 772-1213 or the Railroad Retirement Board at (877) 772-5772 for railroad workers.
The Unexpected Tax Challenge
While the benefit restoration brought relief to millions, it also created an unforeseen tax burden that caught many recipients off guard. Large retroactive payments can push recipients into higher tax brackets, potentially making up to 85% of their Social Security benefits taxable for the year they received the lump sum.
Social Security taxation depends on “combined income,” which includes adjusted gross income, tax-exempt interest, plus half of Social Security benefits. This calculation can become complex when large retroactive payments are involved, as they’re typically counted as income in the year received, not spread across the years they represent.
The base thresholds that trigger Social Security benefit taxation are relatively low and haven’t been adjusted for inflation since their establishment:
| Filing Status | 50% Taxable Threshold | 85% Taxable Threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Single, Head of Household, Qualifying Surviving Spouse | $25,000 | $34,000 |
| Married Filing Jointly | $32,000 | $44,000 |
| Married Filing Separately (living with spouse) | $0 | $0 |
Financial advisor Robert Chen explains: “A $15,000 retroactive payment could easily push someone over these thresholds, making benefits that were previously tax-free suddenly taxable at rates up to 85%. We’re seeing retirees who never owed taxes on Social Security suddenly facing four-figure tax bills.”
The tax impact varies significantly based on individual circumstances. A single retiree with $20,000 in other income who receives a $12,000 retroactive payment could see their combined income jump to $38,000, making 85% of all their Social Security benefits taxable. For someone in the 22% tax bracket, this could result in an unexpected tax bill of several thousand dollars.
To address this issue, Rep. Lance Gooden, R-Texas, introduced the bipartisan No Tax on Restored Benefits Act. This legislation aims to amend the tax code to exclude retroactive Social Security payments specifically tied to the WEP and GPO repeal from income calculations.
Tax expert Sarah Rodriguez notes: “The proposed legislation recognizes that these payments represent benefits that should have been received years ago, not new income that should face current-year taxation. It’s similar to how some other retroactive government payments are treated under existing tax law.”
Implementation Status and Next Steps
The Social Security Administration has demonstrated remarkable efficiency in implementing the sweeping changes required by the Social Security Fairness Act. Within months of the law’s enactment, the agency processed over 3.2 million benefit recalculations and distributed billions in retroactive payments.
The SSA developed specialized computer systems to automatically recalculate benefits, removing WEP and GPO reductions from existing cases. This automated process handled the vast majority of straightforward cases, while more complex situations required manual review by trained specialists.
Only four complex cases remain under review, typically involving survivor beneficiaries with multiple pension sources or unusual circumstances requiring special handling to ensure accurate benefit restoration. These cases often involve foreign pensions, railroad benefits, or situations where beneficiaries have multiple government pensions from different jurisdictions.
Once processed, beneficiaries typically receive a one-time retroactive lump sum covering January 2024 through the processing date, plus adjusted monthly payments going forward. The timing of payments varied, with most recipients seeing their first restored benefits within 60-90 days of the law’s effective date.
The SSA sends detailed explanation letters with each payment, breaking down how benefits were recalculated and what changes recipients can expect in future months. These letters include the previous benefit amount, the WEP or GPO reduction that was removed, and the new benefit amount.
Benefits specialist Maria Santos advises: “Recipients should keep all documentation from the SSA, as these letters will be crucial for tax preparation and may help demonstrate eligibility for any future tax relief legislation. The letters clearly show that payments represent restored benefits rather than new income.”
The agency has also updated its online services, allowing beneficiaries to view their benefit history and see the impact of the WEP and GPO elimination on their personal Social Security Statement. The SSA provides an online tool to calculate the taxable portion of benefits on their official website, helping recipients understand their potential tax obligations.
Looking ahead, the SSA continues monitoring for any additional cases that might qualify for benefit restoration, particularly as individuals approach retirement age or apply for survivor benefits. The agency estimates that ongoing implementation will affect approximately 200,000 new beneficiaries annually as more public sector workers reach retirement age.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to take action to receive my restored benefits?
No action is required unless you’ve changed your address or banking information since your last contact with Social Security.
Will these retroactive payments affect my taxes?
Potentially yes. Large lump sum payments may push you into higher tax brackets, making more of your Social Security benefits taxable.
How can I calculate how much of my Social Security is taxable?
The Social Security Administration provides an online calculator on their website to help determine the taxable portion of your benefits based on your combined income.
What if I haven’t received my retroactive payment yet?
Contact the Social Security Administration at (800) 772-1213 if you believe you’re eligible but haven’t received your payment within 90 days of the law’s effective date.
Will the No Tax on Restored Benefits Act help me?
If passed, this legislation would exclude retroactive payments from the WEP and GPO repeal from taxable income, potentially providing significant tax relief.
Are survivor benefits also restored under this act?
Yes, survivor benefits that were reduced under the GPO are also restored, though these cases may require additional processing time for complex situations involving multiple pensions.